During World War II, blackout drills periodically extinguished New York City’s billboards, skyscrapers, and street lights. Military officers worried that light would outline ships for German pilots and submarine captains, so patriotic volunteers went house to house to enforce the drill and turn the city dark as chocolate. More specifically: as dark as a cake made in Ebinger’s Bakery in Brooklyn.
The Ebinger’s story began in 1898, when George and Catherine opened a namesake bakery on Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn. Their chocolate cake, made from three layers of devil’s-food cake, dark chocolate pudding, chocolate frosting, and chocolate cake crumb topping, became the most iconic of their 200-something offerings. It was decadent and difficult to make—the family kept the recipe secret. It’s unclear when the Ebingers first made the cake, but wartime blackout drills gave it its name: blackout cake. Brooklynites reacted with visceral excitement when they saw the string-tied, pale green box that housed the cake. Locally, it became a quintessential holiday, birthday, and gift cake.
From Park Slope to Avenue M, blackout cake defined the borough for generations of Brooklynites who grew up during Ebinger’s 70-year reign. Decades later, residents describe the cake and the bakery as larger-than-life: “It isn’t just cake!” one man told the New York Times in 1991. “Ebinger’s was a way of life. The Boxes! The stores! You could eat off the floors! The Ebinger’s girls!”
In an area saturated with immigrant-run bakeries, the Ebingers grew their business to over 50 bakeries. Despite Ebinger’s steady rise to fame, though, the company collapsed abruptly in 1972. Unsustainable expansion, fat fearmongering, and the rise of the supermarket culminated in Ebinger’s demise. The company went bankrupt, and the Brooklyn blackout cake disappeared.
Many bakers have since recreated the time-consuming, ingredient-heavy cake. But no one knows Ebinger’s recipe, so no one has tasted the original in decades.
Need to Know
Notable bakeries around Brooklyn make a rendition of the blackout cake, but the original cake hasn't been made in over 40 years.
Visit New York City with Atlas Obscura Trips
Only in Queens: Tasting Our Way Through New York’s Most Diverse Borough
Manhattan may have name-brand recognition and Brooklyn a certain cache, but Queens is the city’s largest and most diverse borough. Join us, May 17–20, to dig into Queens’ rich neighborhood life.
Where to Try It
This bakery offers special-order blackout cake with 24-hour advance notice. Their website lists additional locations in New York and has order forms for local deliveries.
Ladybird Bakery1112 8th Avenue, Brooklyn, New York, 11215, United States
This Park Slope bakery makes Brooklyn blackout cakes and cupcakes.