Trips Places Foods Stories Newsletters
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...

No search results found for
“”

Make sure words are spelled correctly.

Try searching for a travel destination.

Places near me Random place

Popular Destinations

  • Paris
  • London
  • New York
  • Berlin
  • Rome
  • Los Angeles
Trips Places Foods Stories Newsletters
Sign In Join
Places near me Random place
All the United States New York State New York City Manhattan Marble Hill

Marble Hill

Manhattan and the Bronx have been playing tug-of-war over this former island neighborhood for more than a century.

New York, New York

Added By
Luke Spencer
Email
Been Here
Want to go
Added to list
CAPTION
An overview of the Marble Hill neighborhood, seen from the west.   Dwayne Bent/cc by-sa 2.0
The Marble Hill Metro North station.   Ajay Suresh/cc by 2.0
The Harlem River Canal and Marble Hill   Luke J Spencer / Atlas Obscura User
Marble Hill   Luke J Spencer / Atlas Obscura User
Site of the original creek.   Luke J Spencer / Atlas Obscura User
Marble Hill   Luke J Spencer / Atlas Obscura User
Marble Hill   Luke J Spencer / Atlas Obscura User
St. Stephen’s Church of Marble Hill   Luke J Spencer / Atlas Obscura User
A map from 1896 showing the creation of Marble Hill island.   Public Domain
  wherearewedude / Atlas Obscura User
  wherearewedude / Atlas Obscura User
  wherearewedude / Atlas Obscura User
  wherearewedude / Atlas Obscura User
Been Here
Want to go
Added to list

About

Despite being one of the most famous islands in the world, there is a small part of Manhattan that actually makes up part of mainland America: the quaint neighborhood of Marble Hill.

Named after the dolomite marble deposits visible on the stoney crags overlooking the Hudson River, Marble Hill, while physically part of the Bronx, is technically still part of Manhattan. For the citizens of Marble Hill, it is a controversial dispute started by an engineering solution to the problem of Manhattan's busy waterways in the late 19th century. 

With dense shipping overcrowding the Harlem and Hudson Rivers, the two waterways were finally connected in 1895 by the Harlem Ship Canal. It cut through Manhattan's northernmost neighborhood, Marble Hill, immediately turning the latter into an island, cut off from Manhattan on one side by the new canal, and from the Bronx on the other by the old Spuyten Duyvil Creek. Marble Hill kept its proud island status until 1914, when the old creek was eventually filled in, making it physically part of the Bronx, but still legally part of Manhattan. 

A dispute over the neighborhood caught between two boroughs has raged ever since. In March 1939, Bronx Borough president James Lyons climbed the hilltop at 225th Street and planted a Bronx flag, claiming the neighborhood be subservient to his borough. He called it the "Bronx Sudetenland," referencing Germany's recent annexation of part of then-Czechoslovakia. The proud Manhattanite citizens of Marble Hill booed him down, and petitioned the city governor to make sure they remained part of Manhattan. The petition was settled in 1984 declaring the neighborhood once and for all part of Manhattan. 

Today, Marble Hill itself still resembles a quaint village. Small wooden family homes, built in the Queen Anne style with porches and gardens, nestle alongside each other on the winding, steep streets that still bear the Dutch names of its original founders. The unusual curved streets follow the path of the filled in, old Spuyten Duyvil Creek, giving Marble Hill its atypical feel. As recently as 2014, the so-called "Great and Glorious Grand Army of the Bronx" planted their borough flag again in Marble Hill, demanding that the residents declare their "loyalty to the mightiest, most glorious and obviously, most handsome, borough and county of The Bronx," only for Manhattan borough President Gale Brewer to retort that, "On the 75th anniversary of its would-be annexation by the Bronx, I am happy to declare that the flag that flies over Marble Hill is still that of the Manhattan archipelago."

For the several thousand residents who proudly call Marble Hill home, it's a debate that has raged since the canal was built, creating their idiosyncratic neighborhood over 100 years ago. 

Related Tags

Eccentric Homes Territorial Dispute Borders Islands Canals Homes

Community Contributors

Added By

Luke J Spencer

Edited By

Martin, Meg, wherearewedude

  • Martin
  • Meg
  • wherearewedude

Published

February 18, 2015

Edit this listing

Make an Edit
Add Photos
Sources
  • http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/bronx/marble-hill-caught-boroughs-article-1.1781901
  • http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marble_Hill,_Manhattan#Separation_from_Manhattan
Marble Hill
Marble Hill
New York, New York, 10463
United States
40.876117, -73.910263
Get Directions

Nearby Places

West 230th Step Street

Bronx, New York

miles away

Seaman-Drake Arch

New York, New York

miles away

Villa Charlotte Brontë

Bronx, New York

miles away

Explore the Destination Guide

Photo of New York

New York

New York

Places 405
Stories 89

Nearby Places

West 230th Step Street

Bronx, New York

miles away

Seaman-Drake Arch

New York, New York

miles away

Villa Charlotte Brontë

Bronx, New York

miles away

Explore the Destination Guide

Photo of New York

New York

New York

Places 405
Stories 89

Related Stories and Lists

10 Unusual Border Feuds Around the World

List

By Meg Neal

10 Places Caught Up in Odd Border Disputes

geographic markers

By Meg Neal

Related Places

  • Hans Island

    Denmark / Canada

    Hans Island

    A long-disputed island that Denmark and Canada claim by periodically alternating flags and bottles of liquor.

  • Seal in front, Machias Seal Island and lighthouse in back

    United States / Canada

    Machias Seal Island

    The only land territory disputed between the U.S. and Canada.

  • Just Room Enough Island

    Wellesley Island, New York

    Just Room Enough Island

    This tiny little island has, as the name says, just enough room for its single house.

  • No Man’s Land

    Seaview, England

    No Man's Land

    This foolish Victorian sea fort was converted to a deluxe hotel.

  • The Mad Colored Houses of Burano

    Venice, Italy

    The Mad Colored Houses of Burano

    This community on a small Venetian island has taken to painting their houses in bright neon hues.

  • Jindo, South Korea

    Jindo-Modo Landbridge

    Landbridge created by the South Korean version of Moses.

  • One of the famous reed islands on the world’s highest navigable lake.

    Puno, Peru

    The Uros People of Lake Titicaca

    The Uros people live on floating reed islands in lake Titicaca.

  • The side of the Clingstone House. (wallyg/Flickr)

    Jamestown, Rhode Island

    Clingstone House

    Eco-friendly island mansion.

Aerial image of Vietnam, displaying the picturesque rice terraces, characterized by their layered, verdant fields.
Atlas Obscura Membership

Become an Atlas Obscura Member


Join our community of curious explorers.

Become a Member

Get Our Email Newsletter

Follow Us

Facebook YouTube TikTok Instagram Pinterest RSS Feed

Get the app

Download the App
Download on the Apple App Store Get it on Google Play
  • All Places
  • Latest Places
  • Most Popular
  • Places to Eat
  • Random
  • Nearby
  • Add a Place
  • Stories
  • Food & Drink
  • Itineraries
  • Lists
  • Video
  • Podcast
  • Newsletters
  • All Trips
  • Family Trip
  • Food & Drink
  • History & Culture
  • Wildlife & Nature
  • FAQ
  • Membership
  • Feedback & Ideas
  • Community Guidelines
  • Product Blog
  • Unique Gifts
  • Work With Us
  • About
  • FAQ
  • Advertise With Us
  • Advertising Guidelines
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms of Use
Atlas Obscura

© 2025 Atlas Obscura. All Rights Reserved.