Built in 1872 and known then as the Blackwell Island Lighthouse, the fifty-foot-tall stone lighthouse at the northern tip of Roosevelt Island was, sadly, not built as legend would have it, by the deranged occupants of the nearby insane asylum. In reality, it was built by the city as a navigation aid for boats avoiding the rocks in the so-called “Hell Gate” waters, possibly with the help of forced labor of the inmates of the island’s prison.
The legends of its origin are recounted on a sign near the lighthouse:
“The legendary mysteries are the names of Asylum inmate(s?) John McCarthy and Thomas Maxey and whether these two names refer to one person, two people, or even existent people. Supposedly, before the lighthouse was built, McCarthy (or Maxey), fearing a British invasion, was constructing a four-foot-high clay fort on this site. Asylum officials let him finish the fort because, during his adrenaline-rushed work, he reclaimed significant areas of marsh. (They even gave him old Civil War cannons as encouragement.) When the city wanted to build the Lighthouse, officials bribed or persuaded McCarthy either to give up or to demolish the fort.
Whether McCarthy complied or not is the choice of the storyteller, but the fort did come down. Then, supposedly, another asylum patient was summoned to build the lighthouse. This inmate styled himself “Thomas Maxey, Esq., architect, mason, carpenter, civil engineer, philosopher, and philanthropist.” The lighthouse was built, though adherence to Renwick’s blueprint is questionable. Despite Thomas Maxey’s supposed labor, John McCarthy’s name was credited on a plaque that remained at the Lighthouse’s base until its mysterious disappearance in the 1960s:
‘This work was done by John McCarty who built the lighthouse from the bottom to the top all ye who do pass by may pray for his soul when he dies.’”
It was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1972 and made a New York City Landmark in 1976.
The lighthouse grounds were damaged during Hurricane Sandy in 2013, and as of summer 2013, the lighthouse is off limits behind security fencing.